100 West 58th Street, Manhattan, NY 10019

The 15-story, 102-unit building at 100 West 58th Street in Midtown, owned by Robert Orley, has been in operation since 1926 and has experienced a range of maintenance and compliance issues over recent years. The property currently has several active Department of Buildings violations as of 2023/2024, including failures to submit required benchmarking reports of energy use and a critical examination report of exterior walls. The building has also shown consistent food safety concerns, with multiple reported cases of food poisoning between 2023 and 2025, though these were deemed isolated incidents by health authorities.

There have been significant maintenance issues, particularly regarding the 6th-floor apartment (6F), where violations for water leaks, defective plaster surfaces, and door repair requirements were issued in 2019 and remain open. The building has experienced odor issues, with a sewage odor complaint in 2024 resulting in an advisory to the owner, and multiple complaints regarding cooking gas and appliance concerns in 2021. Housing Maintenance Code complaints and violations in 2022-2023 focused on various interior issues including paint/plaster problems on walls and ceilings, flooring concerns, and water leaks, though most were resolved or closed without violations.

The building has maintained a clean record regarding bedbugs, with all annual filings since 2019 showing zero infested units. Historical maintenance records show routine permit issuance for various types of work, including electrical, plumbing, and general repairs, suggesting ongoing maintenance and upkeep of building systems. While the building has passed rodent inspections in 2010-2012, the most recent environmental monitoring and inspection history indicates a pattern of compliance issues, particularly regarding documentation requirements under applicable NYC codes.