257 West 86th Street, Manhattan, NY 10024

257 West 86th Street is a 14-story, 32-unit residential building located in Manhattan's Upper West Side, constructed in 1907 and classified as a New Law Tenement. The property, currently owned by Lewis Kruger, has experienced several significant events that impact resident safety and comfort. Most notably, there is an ongoing concern regarding construction lead dust in common areas, with a complaint filed in November 2022 that remains in progress as of July 2025.

The building has undergone regular inspections and addressed various maintenance issues, including two Environmental Control Board violations from 2018 related to exterior maintenance and documentation requirements, which were resolved with penalties totaling $3,125. While three separate complaints were filed in 2019 (regarding tenant safety, illegal activity, and local law audits), none resulted in violations upon inspection. Bedbug reports have consistently shown zero infested units since 2019, suggesting effective pest management practices.

The building has maintained a generally good record with rodent inspections, having passed the most recent compliance inspection in March 2025, though there was one failed inspection in January 2025 for unspecified reasons. Multiple work permits have been issued for various repairs and improvements between 2020 and 2022, including electrical and plumbing work. The property has demonstrated responsiveness to regulatory requirements, including the passing of routine local law audits and safety inspections, though the ongoing lead dust issue in common areas represents a significant and unresolved concern for current residents.