1616 Amsterdam Avenue, Manhattan, NY 10031

The 52-unit, 7-story New Law Tenement at 1616 Amsterdam Avenue, built in 1916 and currently owned by Benjamin Hadap, has experienced several concerning issues over the past 18 months. Most notably, there is an active investigation regarding a food poisoning incident from June 2025, and recent health department findings have identified rodent activity in June 2025, following similar issues in 2024 and multiple rat sightings earlier in 2025. The building has also faced significant maintenance challenges, including ongoing pest control concerns with multiple unsanitary condition complaints filed in 2025, some of which remain open.

Housing code violations from 2024 reveal problems with mold, floor damage, and various maintenance issues in multiple units (notably apartment 4H) that require attention. The building's infrastructure has shown persistent problems, with multiple Department of Buildings violations indicating water drainage issues, electrical problems, and facade maintenance concerns. Two active ECB violations from late 2024 involve cracked terra-cotta at the building's parapet and unauthorized removal of public protection from an unsafe facade.

The building's elevator service has also been a recurring issue, with complaints about single-device operation and lack of alternate service. Inspections have revealed rat activity throughout 2023-2025, despite some inspections passing. While there are no current bedbug infestations reported in the last three years, the building's maintenance records show a pattern of unresolved violations and service requests, particularly regarding water damage, electrical systems, and building safety features.