559 West 191st Street, Manhattan, NY 10040

559 West 191st Street is a 6-story, 30-unit New Law Tenement building constructed in 1923, currently owned by Stuart Goldstein. The building has experienced persistent maintenance and safety issues over recent years, particularly concerning rodent infestations, with multiple inspections in 2024-2025 showing "Rat Activity" confirmed on April 30, 2025, and the building failing initial rodent inspections in both January and April 2025.

The property has also faced significant plumbing and safety concerns, particularly evident in a cluster of complaints from December 2024 that included issues with heat and hot water, window guard safety, and various plumbing problems, though HPD inspectors were frequently unable to gain access for proper inspection. Violations were documented in November 2024 for Apartment 51, including both lead paint hazards and rodent infestation issues, though some violations have since been closed upon certification of correction. The building's recent maintenance history indicates ongoing challenges with basic services and infrastructure, including heating systems and water supply, with multiple emergency complaints regarding heat and hot water in late 2024.

Despite these issues, the building has maintained a record of no bedbug infestations over the last three reporting periods, with the last documented infestation occurring in 2021. The property has undergone several rodent inspections between 2022 and 2025, with varying results, suggesting ongoing efforts to address pest control issues. While some violations have been addressed and closed, including plumbing and lead paint issues in Apartment 51, the persistence of new complaints and failed inspections indicates continuing maintenance challenges that affect resident comfort and safety.