65 Nagle Avenue, Manhattan, NY 10040

The 25-unit, 6-story New Law Tenement at 65 Nagle Avenue in Inwood, owned by Eric Setton and built in 1914, has experienced multiple significant maintenance issues in recent years, with the most pressing concerns emerging in September 2024. During this period, there were multiple complaints regarding unsanitary conditions, including mold and pest infestations, along with a water leak, wall damage, and problems with doors requiring HPD inspections. Violations were issued for some of these issues, while others remain pending resolution.

The building has also been cited for safety concerns, with open violations from September 2024 in apartment 4A regarding missing smoke and carbon monoxide detectors, defective plastered surfaces, and a roach infestation. Additionally, there are active DOB violations for failure to file 2018 external low-pressure inspection and 2017 boiler inspection reports. Earlier maintenance history shows recurring infrastructure and safety concerns, including multiple power outages, door issues, and unsanitary conditions reported through 311 service requests.

The building has faced challenges with rodent activity, as evidenced by multiple inspections between 2022 and 2024, though recent inspections have shown compliance. The property has maintained a consistent record of bedbug management, with no reported infestations in recent years since the single incident in 2020. Recent building improvements are suggested by the issuance of multiple permits in 2018, including plumbing and electrical work, though the current condition of these improvements is not specified in the available data.