258 President Street, Brooklyn, NY 11231

258 President Street is a three-story, four-unit residential building located in Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn, that was built in 1900 and is currently owned by Louis Nicosia. The building has undergone several inspections and faced multiple regulatory requirements over the past decade, with the most significant recent issue being an open Housing Maintenance Code violation from April 2024 related to the failure to file the required annual bedbug report, which is currently unresolved.

This follows a pattern of similar bedbug reporting violations, including open violations from 2022 and 2021, though records indicate zero actual infestations were reported during the relevant filing periods from 2019-2022, with none of the units affected or requiring eradication measures. The building has a documented history of rodent-related issues, with a mouse sighting reported and investigated by the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene in February 2020, resulting in violations that required follow-up inspections.

Prior to that, there were two failed rodent inspections in August and September 2010, though a subsequent compliance inspection passed. The property's record shows some recurring administrative compliance issues, particularly with bedbug reporting requirements, though the absence of any reported infestations or eradication efforts may suggest these violations are primarily administrative rather than indicative of actual pest problems. The most recent rodent-related incident was over three years ago, in early 2020.