42 Butler Street, Brooklyn, NY 11231

The three-story, three-unit residential building at 42 Butler Street in Carroll Gardens, owned by Sahin Cetinkaya, has been grappling with persistent pest management issues over the past several years. Most recently, in May 2024, the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene documented violations related to rodent sightings, with subsequent inspections confirming rat activity through early 2025.

The building's maintenance history reveals multiple recurring violations related to bedbug reporting compliance between 2021 and 2024, with four consecutive years of citations regarding the failure to file annual bedbug reports as required under Housing Maintenance Code regulations. The property's rodent issues have been particularly noteworthy, with documented rat activity confirmed at least five times between July 2023 and January 2025, including initial and compliance inspections.

The building's age (constructed in 1899) and classification as an Old Law Tenement may present unique maintenance challenges, though the most pressing current concerns appear to center around vermin control and compliance with health department requirements. The persistence of these issues over multiple years and various inspections suggests an ongoing challenge with pest management in the building, though the records indicate that health authorities continue to monitor the situation through scheduled follow-up inspections.