58 Conselyea Street, Brooklyn, NY 11211

The three-story, three-unit OLD LAW TENEMENT building at 58 Conselyea Street in Williamsburg, owned by 58 Conselyea, LLC, has faced persistent rat activity and maintenance challenges over recent years. Most notably, between 2024 and 2025, there has been ongoing rodent activity requiring multiple bait applications, with inspections consistently finding evidence of rat presence.

The building's rodent issues date back several years, with 311 complaints recorded in 2018, 2019, 2020, 2024, and 2025, including both sightings and conditions attracting rodents. The property has also grappled with heat and hot water issues, as evidenced by a May 2020 emergency complaint, though HPD confirmed restoration of services shortly thereafter. The building's maintenance record shows some concerning patterns, including three consecutive annual violations (2021-2023) related to the failure to file mandatory bedbug reports, though the most recent filings from late 2024 indicate no infestation issues during the reporting periods.

Additionally, a May 2020 violation noted problems with self-closing doors at the front entrance. While the building has maintained regular rodent control efforts, as shown by consistent bait applications since 2020 and internal inspections, the recurring nature of rodent complaints suggests ongoing challenges with pest management. The property has demonstrated compliance with bedbug reporting requirements in recent years, with all filings showing zero infested units, though previous violations indicate historical noncompliance.