258 Withers Street, Brooklyn, NY 11211
258 Withers Street is a 3-story, 6-unit residential building constructed in 1930 and currently owned by Shloma Stuhl. The property has experienced several maintenance issues in recent years, with the most significant problems occurring in late 2019-2020. These included multiple heat and hot water complaints affecting both individual apartments and the entire building, with some tenants reporting restoration of services during HPD inspections.
The building has also faced pest-related challenges, as evidenced by rodent complaints in early 2020 and a documented rat sighting in the same period. A notable Housing Maintenance Code violation from February 2020 cited defective self-closing doors in apartment 1R, though this was subsequently repaired. The building underwent significant scrutiny in 2019 regarding unauthorized unit conversions, with multiple Environmental Control Board violations issued for converting and occupying the property with three or more additional dwelling units beyond its legally authorized configuration.
The DOB had issued a stop work order related to plumbing modifications in December 2018, which was subsequently resolved. More recent inspections from 2021-2022 have shown improved compliance, with no reported infestations in the building's bedbug reporting history from 2020 to 2025. Rodent inspections conducted between 2012-2016 demonstrated varying levels of rodent activity, though the most recent inspections passed without issue. As of July 2025, the building's most recent bedbug filings indicate a clean record, with no units reporting infestation, eradication, or re-infestation during the 2023-2024 reporting period.
258 Withers Street Report Contents
Download Full Report for 258 Withers Street
Sign up to download the full building report in PDF or Excel format
Sign Up for Free258 Withers Street Building Overview
Building Characteristics
Total units | 6 |
---|---|
Year built | 1930 |
Total area | 5625 sq ft |
Floors | 3 |
Tax Abatements | None |
Building Class | NEW LAW TENEMENT |

Unlock Complete Building History
Get access to comprehensive violation records, court cases, landlord portfolios, and detailed maintenance history for this building and thousands of others.
Key Building Statistics
Map and Aerial View of 258 Withers Street
Street Map View
Loading street map...
Satellite View
Loading satellite view...
Reviews of 258 Withers Street
See what current and past tenants have to say
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your experience living at this property. Your review helps future tenants make informed decisions.
Share Your Experience
Help future tenants by leaving an honest review of this property
Login Required
You must be logged in to leave a review. Join our community and share your experience!
Login to Continue