249 East 51st Street, Brooklyn, NY 11203

249 East 51st Street is a 3-story, 6-unit residential building constructed in 1931, currently owned by James Coleman. The property has experienced recurring heating system issues, with documented complaints about lack of heat and hot water in both 2021 and 2023 affecting the entire building. In 2024, two notable violations were identified in Apartment 4, including water leak issues and defective plastered surfaces, though these were certified as corrected by late 2024.

A total of 14 different maintenance complaints were filed between 2021 and 2023, covering various issues including plumbing problems (affecting sinks, bathtubs, and toilets), pest infestations, and appliance malfunctions, with multiple complaints requiring repeated reporting due to inspection access issues. The building's systems and safety features require attention, as evidenced by 2024 violations noting problems with fire escape access in Apartments 4 and 5, and the need for carbon monoxide detectors in Apartment 5. An August 2022 boiler inspection resulted in an Environmental Control Board violation regarding chimney cleanout and steam controls, with a penalty of $312 that has since been resolved.

The property has maintained a consistent record of bedbug-free status from 2019 through 2024, with zero reported infestations. Historical rodent inspections conducted in 2015 and 2020 both resulted in passing grades, indicating effective pest management in that regard. Recent maintenance activity includes multiple repairs and inspections as of late 2024, with violations involving the building's roof, public hall ceiling, and various apartment-specific issues. The building's history shows a pattern of maintenance challenges that typically require multiple tenant complaints to achieve resolution, particularly regarding heating systems and plumbing infrastructure.