8609 Bay 16th Street, Brooklyn, NY 11214

8609 Bay 16th Street is a 4-story, 32-unit New Law Tenement building constructed in 1924 and currently owned by Eve Vasilantonakis. The property has experienced persistent maintenance issues in recent months, with the most pressing concerns being pest infestations, window safety violations, and mold problems. Between April and June 2025 alone, there were multiple HPD inspections resulting in violations for unsanitary conditions (particularly related to pests), window guard safety concerns, mold presence, and water leaks.

A December 2024 inspection of Apartment C2 revealed several violations including leaky bathtub faucets, a defective smoke detector, visible mold (less than 10 sq ft), and a roach infestation, though some of these violations have since been marked as closed. The building's infrastructure and external conditions have also raised concerns, with active ECB violations from August 2024 citing facade disrepair, cracks, missing mortar joints, and debris obstructing emergency egress at the fire escape. These violations carry significant penalties totalling $3,750.

Additionally, there have been recurring issues with elevator service, building shaking concerns, and a history of illegal conversion complaints. Notably, the building experienced a severe bedbug infestation in 2020-2021, affecting 33 units, though subsequent years show no reported infestations. The property's maintenance history suggests ongoing challenges with basic upkeep and safety compliance, particularly regarding pest control and building infrastructure.