558 Castleton Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10301

The 2-story, 22-unit building at 558 Castleton Avenue in West Brighton, built in 1947 and owned by Castleton Associates LLC, has experienced several maintenance issues over the past few years, with the most recent being an emergency mold complaint filed in June 2025. The property has a pattern of water-related issues, including a significant water leak and mold problem documented in November 2020 that affected Apartment 1, though these violations were later closed. Other notable incidents include a heat/hot water problem in May 2021, reported pests in August 2022, and various unsanitary conditions related to garbage/recycling storage in June 2019.

The building has maintained an active bedbug reporting record since 2019, consistently reporting zero infested units in annual filings through 2024, indicating no documented infestations during this period. The building has some ongoing compliance matters, including four active violations from 2018 related to unpermitted work on gas fittings in the cellar, with associated penalties totaling $2,910. These violations remain unresolved as of the latest available data.

Between 2020-2024, multiple housing maintenance code violations were recorded and subsequently closed, including issues with ceiling plaster/paint in Apartment 1, water leak repairs, and mold abatement. The property's heating system has also experienced periodic issues, with emergency heating complaints recorded in both 2021 and 2020. While the building has faced various maintenance challenges, most recent complaints have been addressed promptly, with the exception of the 2018 gas fitting violations and the recent 2025 mold complaint.