219 North Burgher Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10310

The two-family house at 219 North Burgher Avenue in Randall Manor, owned by Giuseppe La Fata, has a documented history of maintenance issues, particularly affecting the first-floor apartment (Apartment 1). Most recently, in July 2023, multiple Housing Maintenance Code violations were issued, including problems with doors, a defective carbon monoxide detector, and evidence of a roach infestation.

The building experienced numerous documented issues during April-May 2022, with violations related to water leaks, mold, door and window problems, and rodent conditions. These complaints led to the Department of Housing Preservation and Development conducting multiple inspections, some resulting in violations that can be checked on the HPD website.

The property's documented rodent inspection history shows a pattern of compliance issues from 2010-2012, with failed inspections in both initial and compliance tests during 2011-2012, followed by a period of passing inspections thereafter. The building's most recent violation history from 2023 suggests ongoing maintenance challenges, particularly affecting door functionality, safety systems (such as carbon monoxide detection), and pest control. While many of the older violations have been closed out, the frequency and variety of issues logged in both 2022 and through 2023 inspections indicate a consistent pattern of maintenance needs, particularly affecting the first-floor unit.