3 Trinity Place, Staten Island, NY 10310

The three-unit, three-story building at 3 Trinity Place in Randall Manor, owned by Marie Elliott, has experienced several maintenance issues since 2019, with the most significant recent concerns occurring between November and December 2023. The building's heating and hot water systems have been recurrent problems, most notably in November 2023 when violations were issued for inadequate heat supply and excessively hot water (over 130 degrees) in a fourth-floor apartment, along with an access issue to the heating system.

Prior to this, similar heating/hot water service complaints were reported through 311 in 2023, and emergency violations were filed for various issues in late 2019 through early 2020, including toilet problems, plumbing issues, and ceiling paint/plaster concerns. The building's maintenance record shows a consistent pattern of plumbing-related incidents, including multiple complaints about toilet and sink issues between 2019 and 2020, though most of these resulted in no violations being issued. In terms of health and safety compliance, the building has maintained an active bedbug reporting record over the past four years (2021-2024) showing zero infestation cases, with the most recent inspection on May 9, 2024, resulting in a passed compliance status.

However, two Class A violations were noted in 2023 related to failure to file annual bedbug reports with HPD. The property has also undergone rodent inspections, with a passed compliance result in May 2024 following an initial detection of rat activity in February 2024. While the building's age (constructed in 1899) and relatively small size (3 units) present unique maintenance challenges, the owner has generally responded to service requests, with most recent violations being closed promptly, though the persistent nature of heating and plumbing issues suggests ongoing system maintenance requirements.