1096 Castleton Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10310

The two-family house at 1096 Castleton Avenue in West Brighton, Staten Island, currently owned by Thomas Spinelli, has experienced several concerning maintenance issues over the past two years. Most recently, in April 2025, the property received multiple Housing Preservation Department (HPD) violations related to pest infestations, which were documented through 311 service requests and Housing Maintenance Code complaints.

These complaints were resolved through inspections, though the property owner was issued violations that required correction. Earlier in December 2024, the building faced a series of significant issues, including water leak problems categorized as "heavy flow," mold concerns, and pest-related unsanitary conditions, all of which were classified as emergency situations requiring immediate attention.

The property also experienced ceiling-related paint/plaster issues during this period, though these were investigated and determined not to violate housing laws. The pattern of complaints suggests ongoing maintenance challenges, with particularly notable concerns regarding moisture-related problems, including leaks and mold, which can impact both habitability and resident health. The building, constructed in 1920, shows a concerning trend of requiring multiple interventions from housing authorities, particularly relating to pest control and moisture management.