558 Main Street, Staten Island, NY 10307

The two-family house at 558 Main Street in Tottenville, owned by Saleha Siddiqi, has experienced some concerning issues in recent years, most notably a heat and hot water emergency reported in February 2025. The complaint, which was filed with both the HPD and the Housing Maintenance Code Complaints department, could not be properly investigated as inspectors were unable to gain access to the apartments for verification.

This recent heating system problem marks the second heat-related incident in the building's history, though the earlier complaint from 2025 was similarly unresolved due to access issues. Additionally, there was an investigation into an illegal conversion at the property in March 2020, which remained open through March 2021 when inspectors made a second and final attempt to gain access but were unable to conduct their inspection. The building, constructed in 1989, is classified as a two-family house and consists of two stories.

It has experienced minimal documented issues over its history, with the heat and hot water complaints constituting the most significant recent concerns. The illegal conversion complaint from 2020/2021 may suggest prior occupancy changes that were not properly documented, though the lack of access during inspections limits the conclusions that can be drawn about the building's current configuration. While the heat and hot water problems represent the most immediate concern for residents, the repeated access issues faced by inspectors in both the heating complaint and the illegal conversion investigation suggest communication challenges between building management and regulatory agencies.