160 Bethel Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10307

The two-family house at 160 Bethel Avenue in Tottenville, owned by Lawrence Erra, was constructed in 1930 and spans two stories with four units. The building has experienced recurring issues with moisture and sanitation, most notably evidenced by three separate unsanitary condition complaints regarding mold, with the most recent emergency complaint filed in November 2024.

The property has a documented history of maintenance challenges dating back to October 2018, when multiple complaints were filed simultaneously with the Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD) regarding various issues including plumbing problems with sinks and bathtubs/showers, safety concerns regarding non-functioning smoke and carbon monoxide detectors, issues with flooring, and problems with a refrigerator. Despite the severity of these complaints, HPD was unable to gain access to inspect the reported conditions, and the complaints were subsequently closed.

Between October 2018 and November 2024, the building's maintenance record shows a concerning pattern of unresolved issues, particularly regarding safety systems and moisture-related problems. The emergency nature of several 2018 complaints, including those related to smoke detectors and carbon monoxide detectors, suggests potential safety concerns, though these specific issues may have been addressed following the complaints' resolution. The building's age (95 years) and documented history of maintenance issues may require ongoing attention to basic systems and safety features, as evidenced by the repeated nature of complaints regarding plumbing, safety systems, and unsanitary conditions.