5844 N Magnolia Ave
This building has more problems than most buildings in this neighborhood. A handful of unresolved issues. Worth a careful walk-through and pointed questions.
This building has 3 building violations (7y), above the Edgewater average of 2.1.
What's in the 5844 N Magnolia Ave report
| Units | 3 |
|---|---|
| Year built | 1916 |
| Stories | — |
| Building area | 6,315 sq ft |
| Property class | 211 |
| PIN (Cook County parcel) | 14053100550000 |
Registered owner per Cook County Assessor records.
Landlord portfolio
Other Chicago properties this owner holds, with risk grades for each.
Unlock complete reportThe three-unit residential building at 5844 N Magnolia Ave in Chicago's Edgewater neighborhood, owned by James & Becky McTague, has been recorded with several concerning issues in recent years. Built in 1916, this property currently has three unresolved complaint-driven inspection violations as of October 2024, including two newly recorded violations from October 2024, and one from June 2020. The building's service request history over the past seven years shows 24 311 calls, with multiple ongoing issues as of 2026. Notably, there are open requests for tree removal inspection and sidewalk inspection, indicating possible maintenance or safety concerns. The property has also experienced rodent issues, as evidenced by a rodent baiting complaint in July 2025. Other 311 service requests from 2025-2026 include closed complaints about an abandoned vehicle and a pothole in the street, though these are exterior to the building itself and relate more to neighborhood conditions than the building's direct environment. The combination of multiple unresolved violations and ongoing service requests suggests the property may be experiencing various maintenance and environmental challenges that could impact resident comfort and safety.
How 5844 N Magnolia Ave's risk score is calculated
We trained a model on 7 years of Chicago code enforcement data — building violations, 311 complaint history, environmental enforcement, and owner track records. It estimates the probability that the City of Chicago will find a code violation at this address in the next 12 months. Lower % = safer.
What the score means for you
Grade A–B — Low risk
City inspectors rarely find violations here. Strong maintenance history and a clean complaint record.
Grade C — Moderate risk
Some past violations or complaints on record. Worth asking the landlord about any open issues before signing.
Grade D–F — High risk
Elevated violation and complaint history. City inspectors have found issues here before and are statistically likely to again.
Out of 1376 buildings in this neighborhood, 1101 are predicted to be safer.
violation
likely
What's driving this score
The data points that most influenced this building's risk rating — ranked by the weight the model placed on each one.
5844 N Magnolia Ave apartment reviews
Real experiences from people who have lived here. Share yours to help other renters decide.
Share your experience — Help other renters by leaving an honest apartment review
Loading reviews…
Compare nearby alternatives
This building and nearby alternatives in Edgewater, color-coded by risk level. Click any marker to explore.
5844 N Magnolia Ave event timeline
Building violations, environmental complaints and enforcement, permits, scofflaw listings, and 311 calls — most recent records in order.
See all 8 events
Full history back to 2020 — violations, complaints, permits, and 311 calls.
Unlock complete timelineFull data for 5844 N Magnolia Ave apartments
Chicago public datasets for this parcel — building violations, permits, 311 calls, environmental complaints and enforcement, scofflaw listings, and vacant building registrations.
What this is
Violations issued by the City of Chicago Department of Buildings against this parcel.
| Violation # | Date | Category | Status | Address |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Loading… | ||||
What this is
Violations issued for failure to register or maintain a vacant or abandoned building.
| Docket # | Violation # | Issued | Department | Type | Disposition | Total Fines |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Loading… | ||||||
What this is
Building permits issued by the City of Chicago for new construction, alterations, and repairs at this parcel.
| Permit # | Issued | Status | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
| Loading… | |||
What this is
Chicago 311 service requests recorded at this parcel — maintenance complaints and quality-of-life requests.
| SR # | Created | Type | Department | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Loading… | ||||
What this is
Environmental complaints filed about this property with the City of Chicago.
| Complaint # | Date | Type | Inspector | Resolution | Resolved |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Loading… | |||||
What this is
Formal environmental enforcement cases brought against this property.
| Case # | Date | Type | Violation | Disposition | Status | Fine |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Loading… | ||||||
Affordable Rental Housing requires a full report
Included with every paid plan.
Unlock complete reportAsbestos & Demolition Notifications requires a full report
Included with every paid plan.
Unlock complete reportLook up the next apartment before you sign
Search any Chicago address free — no account needed to see the risk rating.
Get the complete picture
Every plan unlocks the complete report: all Chicago datasets, full history, landlord portfolio, and PDF & Excel exports.
Report Bundle
For the buildings you're deciding on right now
$10 one-time
~$3.33 per building. No subscription ever. Each credit unlocks one building's premium report for 30 days.
- 3 full AI-powered reports
- Download PDF reports
- Advanced safety analysis
- Compare multiple buildings
- Credits never expire until you use them
- Full public records (200 rows per dataset)
Apartment Hunter
For a wide search across many buildings
$39 one-time
30 reports — ~$1.30 each. No subscription ever.
- 30 full AI-powered reports
- Download PDF reports
- Advanced safety analysis
- Compare multiple buildings
- Credits never expire until you use them
- Full public records (200 rows per dataset)
Renter
For the weeks when the stakes are highest
$10/mo
Billed $120/year — save $24 vs monthly
- Unlimited basic reports
- 5 premium AI reports per month
- Download PDF & Excel reports
- Full public records (200 rows per dataset)
- Full event timeline — every year of history
- Landlord portfolio & ownership insights
Less than $0.34/day. Cancel anytime.
Cancel anytime · Data sourced from the City of Chicago Department of Buildings, Chicago 311, Cook County Assessor & the Chicago Data Portal