58 Avenue A
This building has a severe track record, and our model predicts major ongoing maintenance failures.
This building has 42 recorded HPD violations, above the East Village average of 14.4.
Is 58 Avenue A rent-stabilized?
Rent stabilization caps how much your rent can rise and protects your right to renew. Here's how this building scores on the four signals that usually point to it.
Based on public NYC records. Not legal advice — verify with the DHCR (Division of Housing and Community Renewal) at apps.hcr.ny.gov.
Get the full picture — it's free
Create a free account to read the AI-generated analysis, see 2× more records across all data categories, and check 10 buildings a month.
How 58 Avenue A's risk score is calculated
We trained a model on 7 years of city inspection data — HPD violation filings, tenant complaints, and owner track records across their entire portfolio. It estimates the probability that HPD inspectors will find serious or dangerous violations at this address in the next 12 months. Lower % = safer.
What the score means for you
Out of 1555 buildings in this neighborhood, 109 have a higher predicted risk.
violations
(1–9)
(10+)
What's driving this score
These are the three data points that most influenced this building's score — ranked by how much weight the model placed on each one.
Don't stop here — this is just the surface.
The full report adds 30+ data sets, complete violation history, landlord portfolio and court record. Or keep reading free:
What's in the 58 Avenue A report
| Total units | 77 |
|---|---|
| Floors | 6 |
| Year built | 1940 |
| Gross area | 75,956 sq ft |
| Building class | — |
| Tax abatement | None |
Violations & complaints per year — solid line is historical record, dashed line is AI projection.
Included addresses
All street addresses that share this building's BBL and are covered by this report.
58 Avenue A's landlord & ownership
The people and companies registered to this building, the other properties they run, and their court record. A landlord's wider portfolio is often the best predictor of how your building will be treated.
Registered contact for this building.
New York, NY 10010
Other properties owned.
Reviews from 58 Avenue A tenants
Real experiences from people who have lived here. Share your honest feedback to help others make informed decisions.
Share your experience — Help other renters by leaving an honest review
Loading reviews…
Compare nearby alternatives
This building and nearby alternatives, color-coded by risk level. Click any marker to explore.
58 Avenue A event timeline
Violations, complaints, fines, and permits — the most recent records on file, in order.
See all 32 events
Full history back to 2021 — violations, complaints, permits, bedbug filings, and more.
Unlock full timelineFull data for 58 Avenue A apartments
30+ public city datasets for this address — searchable and sortable.
What this is
Housing code violations issued by HPD against property conditions. Non-compliance with NYC's Housing Maintenance Code can result in violations and fines.
| Inspection Date | Class | Category | Description | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10/04/2023 | B | Original | § 27-2017.3 Hmc: Trace And Repair The Source And Abate The Visible Mold Condition... At Ceiling Approx 4 Sq.Ft. In The Bathroom Located At Apt 4A, 5Th Story, 2Nd Apartment From West At North Original Violation 16285810 Issued 04-Oct-23 Has Been Upgraded To Class B Per Administrative Code §27-2017.3A(3)(A) Or (B). | Violation Closed |
| 05/29/2025 | A | Original | § 26-1103 Admin. Code: Post And Maintain A Proper Notice On Wall Of The Entrance Story In English And Spanish On The Availability Of The AgencyS Housing Information Guide. A Sample Notice Can Be Found At Www.Nyc.Gov/Hpd. | Violation Closed |
| 05/29/2025 | A | Original | § 27-2104 Adm Code Post And Maintain A Proper Sign On Wall Of Entrance Story Showing The Registration Number Assigned By The Department And The Address Of The Building. | Violation Closed |
| 05/29/2025 | B | Original | § 27-2046.1 Hmc: Repair Or Replace The Carbon Monoxide Detecting Device(S). Missing In The Entire Apartment Located At Apt 1B, 1St Story, 1St Apartment From North At East | Violation Dismissed |
| 05/29/2025 | B | Original | § 27-2045 Adm Code Repair Or Replace The Smoke Detector Missing In The Entire Apartment Located At Apt 1B, 1St Story, 1St Apartment From North At East | Violation Dismissed |
What this is
Complaints filed with HPD about conditions violating the NYC Housing Maintenance Code or NY State Multiple Dwelling Law.
| Received | Category | Type | Status | Apartment |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 02/01/2026 | Door/Window – Door | Emergency | Close | 3H |
| 11/26/2025 | Unsanitary Condition – Pests | Non Emergency | Close | TH1 |
| 11/26/2025 | Unsanitary Condition – Pests | Non Emergency | Close | TH1 |
| 01/29/2026 | Heat/Hot Water – Apartment Only | Emergency | Close | 2M |
| 12/11/2024 | Heat/Hot Water – Entire Building | Emergency | Close | BLDG |
What this is
Service requests logged daily with the city through 311 and tracked to resolution. These are complaints that can be directed to specific city agencies.
| Created Date | Problem | Problem Detail | Agency Name | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 02/01/2026 | Door/Window | Door | Department of Housing Preservation and Development | Closed |
| 01/29/2026 | Heat/Hot Water | Apartment Only | Department of Housing Preservation and Development | Closed |
| 11/26/2025 | Unsanitary Condition | Pests | Department of Housing Preservation and Development | Closed |
| 11/26/2025 | Unsanitary Condition | Pests | Department of Housing Preservation and Development | Closed |
| 08/21/2025 | Rodent | Rat Sighting | Department of Health and Mental Hygiene | Closed |
What this is
All complaints received by the Department of Buildings, including those from 311 and complaints entered directly by DOB staff.
| Filed | Number | Status | Category | Disposition |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/01/2025 | 1711435 | Closed | 1X | 02/19/2026 |
| 07/14/2025 | 1699959 | Closed | 6Y | 07/16/2025 |
| 07/14/2025 | 1699960 | Closed | 6Y | 07/16/2025 |
| 04/17/2025 | 1693506 | Closed | 6V | 04/18/2025 |
| 04/17/2025 | 1693507 | Closed | 6V | 04/18/2025 |
What this is
Civil penalties and violation notices issued by the Department of Buildings for construction and building code violations.
| Issue Date | Category | Type | Description | Disposition |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/18/2025 | V*-Dob Violation - Dismissed | C-Construction Other Optional | Stop All Work Under # M00914385 Due To Notice To Revoke Permit | 02/19/2026 |
| 06/23/2024 | V*-Dob Violation - Dismissed | Earcx-Failure To Submit Eer None | Failure To Submit An Eer Per Ad. Code Sec. 28-308.4 - Multiple Years (2023) | 10/08/2025 |
| 05/02/2024 | V*-Dob Violation - Dismissed | Bench-Failure To Benchmark None | Failure To File Benchmarking Report Of Energy Use As Per Ad. Code Sec. 28-309.4 | 04/09/2025 |
| 05/01/2024 | V*-Dob Violation - Dismissed | Aeuhaz1-Fail To Certify Class 1 None | Failure To Certify Correction On Immediately Hazardous (Class 1) Ecb Violation | 08/16/2024 |
| 03/06/2024 | V*-Dob Violation - Dismissed | Aeuhaz1-Fail To Certify Class 1 None | Failure To Certify Correction On Immediately Hazardous (Class 1) Ecb Violation | 03/14/2024 |
What this is
Summonses and penalties adjudicated by OATH (Office of Administrative Trials & Hearings) and the Environmental Control Board. DOB enforcement cases that have been heard and decided.
| Issue Date | Violation # | Status | Description | Penalty |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 07/14/2025 | 39153586R | Active | Atoi Of A 6-Story Building It Was Observed Bulging And Step Cracking, Throughout Facade . Damaged, Cracked, Spalled. Stone Mortar Joins Deteriorated. &Missing Mortar. Observed Parapet Walls Leaning Toward Backy | $625 |
| 07/14/2025 | 39153583L | Resolve | Atoi Observed Split A/C Hvac Unit Installed Wired With Connection To An Electrical Disconnect Box To Supply Power To A/C Unit, Approximately 60Ft In Height Roof Top Expos3&4 Search Of Dept. Records Indicate Wor | $0 |
| 01/03/2025 | 39134472P | Active | I Observed Mounted Outside On The Right And Rear Of The Building 2 Hvac Units And Disconnect Switches. No Application On File With D.O.T., Obtain Permit., Obtain Permit | $800 |
| 01/03/2025 | 39134471N | Active | I Observed Bx Cable Used As A Permanent Power Source For The Hvac Unit Mounted Outside On The Right Side Of The Building., Comply With Ec | $800 |
| 09/30/2024 | 39126134M | Resolve | 2/M/P Out Side Comm Missing Provide, 8/V/1 Car Floor To Land Sill Not Level Adjust, 99/Bb/7 One Year Tag Expired Provide. | $625 |
OATH Hearings requires a full report
This dataset is included with every paid plan.
Unlock full reportWhat this is
Executed eviction warrants in NYC from 2017-present. Records of completed residential and commercial evictions processed through housing court.
| Executed Date | Docket # | Apartment | Type | Marshal |
|---|
HPD Litigation requires a full report
This dataset is included with every paid plan.
Unlock full reportAEP / Problem Buildings requires a full report
This dataset is included with every paid plan.
Unlock full reportVacate Orders requires a full report
This dataset is included with every paid plan.
Unlock full reportWhat this is
Recorded real estate transactions and property sales. Public records of building transfers and changes in ownership.
| Sale Date | Price | Building Class | Neighborhood | Apartment |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 09/12/2022 | $64,000,000 | D6 | Alphabet City |
What this is
Property owner reports of bedbug infestation status required by NYC law. Building owners must file annual reports on bedbug treatment and infestation history.
| Filing Date | Infested Units | Eradicated | Re-infested | Period End |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/02/2025 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 10/31/2025 |
| 01/02/2025 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 10/31/2024 |
| 08/29/2024 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 10/31/2023 |
| 12/02/2022 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 10/31/2022 |
| 12/22/2021 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 10/31/2021 |
What this is
NYC Department of Health & Mental Hygiene rodent inspection results. Records of inspections for rat and rodent infestation signs.
| Inspection Date | Type | Result |
|---|---|---|
| 03/02/2026 | Compliance | Passed |
| 02/17/2026 | Stoppage | Stoppage Done |
| 01/14/2026 | Initial | Failed For Other Reason |
| 12/22/2025 | Compliance | Passed |
| 08/25/2025 | Initial | Failed For Rat Activity |
Fire Violations requires a full report
This dataset is included with every paid plan.
Unlock full reportFire Inspections requires a full report
This dataset is included with every paid plan.
Unlock full reportFire Certificates requires a full report
This dataset is included with every paid plan.
Unlock full reportWhat this is
Construction and demolition permits issued by the Department of Buildings. Required for legal building, construction, and demolition activities in NYC.
| Filing Date | Type | Work | Floor | Description | Status | Issued |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 03/26/2025 | Initial Permit | Plumbing | Cellar, Floor Number(s) 001 through 006 | Plumbing Work In Conjunction With M01162552-I1. No Change In Egress, Use Or Occupancy. | Permit Issued | 03/26/2025 |
| 03/19/2025 | Initial Permit | General Construction | Cellar, Floor Number(s) 001 through 006, Floor Number(s) 001 through 001 | Propose Interior Renovation On Existing 6 Story Building, Constructions Works As Per Plan.Plumbing Work To Be Filed Under Separate Application. No Change On Egress Use Or Occupancy. | Permit Issued | 03/19/2025 |
| 03/19/2025 | Initial Permit | Mechanical Systems | Cellar, Floor Number(s) 001 through 006, Roof | Mechanical Work On 1St Floor Through Roof. No Change In Egress, Use Or Occupancy. | Permit Issued | 03/19/2025 |
| 08/14/2024 | Initial Permit | Mechanical Systems | Cellar | Installation Of A New Split System Heat Pump Unit & Associateld Piping & Ductwork Along With Erv Units As Indicated On The Drawings Filed Herein. Filed In Conjunction With Gc #M00829836-I1 | Permit Issued | 08/14/2024 |
| 10/16/2023 | Initial Permit | General Construction | Floor Number(s) 1 through 3, Floor Number(s) 5 through 6 | Deferred Maintenance Of Existing Apartments Including The Removal And Installation Of Nonload Bearing Partitions, New Kitchen Cabinets Throughout Apartments As Indicated On Thedrawings Filed Herein. No Change Of Use,Occupancy Or Egress | Signed-Off | 10/16/2023 |
Electrical Permits requires a full report
This dataset is included with every paid plan.
Unlock full reportElevator Permits requires a full report
This dataset is included with every paid plan.
Unlock full reportAsbestos Filings requires a full report
This dataset is included with every paid plan.
Unlock full reportLandmark Violations requires a full report
This dataset is included with every paid plan.
Unlock full reportDOHMH Health Complaints requires a full report
This dataset is included with every paid plan.
Unlock full reportHPD Work Orders requires a full report
This dataset is included with every paid plan.
Unlock full reportWater Connections requires a full report
This dataset is included with every paid plan.
Unlock full reportPlanning Projects requires a full report
This dataset is included with every paid plan.
Unlock full reportHow 58 Avenue A compares to the neighborhood
This building against comparable properties in East Village. Toggle filters to narrow the peer group.
No comparable buildings found with the selected filters. Try removing a filter.
Look up the next building before you sign
Most renters check three or four buildings. Search any NYC address free — no account needed to see the rating.
Get the full picture
Every plan unlocks the complete report: all 30+ record sets, full history, landlord portfolio and court record, plus PDF & Excel exports.
Report Bundle
For the buildings you're deciding on right now
$10 one-time
~$3.33 per building. No subscription ever. Each credit unlocks one building's premium report for 30 days.
- 3 full AI-powered reports
- Download PDF reports
- Advanced safety analysis
- Compare multiple buildings
- Credits never expire until you use them
- Full public records (200 rows per dataset)
Apartment Hunter
For a wide search across many buildings
$39 one-time
30 reports — ~$1.30 each. No subscription ever.
- 30 full AI-powered reports
- Download PDF reports
- Advanced safety analysis
- Compare multiple buildings
- Credits never expire until you use them
- Full public records (200 rows per dataset)
Renter
For the weeks when the stakes are highest
$10/mo
Billed $120/year — save $24 vs monthly
- Unlimited basic reports
- 5 premium AI reports per month
- Download PDF & Excel reports
- Full public records (200 rows per dataset)
- Full event timeline — every year of history
- Landlord portfolio & ownership insights
Less than $0.34/day. Cancel anytime.
Cancel anytime · Data sourced from NYC Open Data, HPD, DOB, DOF & the courts