Free Building Background Check

216 East 5 Street

Manhattan, NY 10003 BBL 1004600019 12 units · 5 floors · 1866

This building has a substantial enforcement record over the last seven years, and our model predicts continuing maintenance failures over the next 12 months. Read the records below before you sign. Ask which issues were resolved, get repair commitments in writing, and inspect the unit yourself.

HPD violations vs. neighborhood
Class B/C violations on record vs. a typical building in East Village
Above average
avg 14.4
128
Fewer violations More violations

This building has 128 recorded HPD violations, above the East Village average of 14.4.

Augrented Insights
Initial analysis

The 12-unit, 5-story residential building at 216 East 5th Street in the East Village, owned by Stephan Moll, was constructed in 1866 and has a concerning record of maintenance and safety issues in recent years. The property currently faces multiple significant problems, including three Class C immediately hazardous violations related to defective self-closing doors and an improperly mounted air conditioning unit, as well as a Class B hazardous violation concerning a radiator shut-off knob in Apartment 9. The building has experienced recurrent pest control issues, with five failed rodent inspections in the past seven years and a cluster of recent rat sighting complaints in August 2026. An alarming pattern of emergency complaints has emerged in 2026, including reports of heat/hot water issues and problems with doors/windows.

AI-generated · may contain errors · check the source data tables below

Free account unlocks the full analysis — plus 2× more records across 8 data categories and the complete landlord portfolio.

What's in the 216 East 5 Street report

Rent & eviction protection

Is 216 East 5 Street rent-stabilized?

Rent stabilization caps how much your rent can rise and protects your right to renew. Here's how this building scores on the four signals that usually point to it.

Built before 1974
Built 1866
6 or more units
12 units
Registered with RGB
Not found
421-A / J-51 abatement
None found
Potential rent stabilization. Building age and size suggest eligibility — confirm with the DHCR (Division of Housing and Community Renewal) or request a rent history.

Based on public NYC records. Not legal advice — verify with the DHCR (Division of Housing and Community Renewal) at apps.hcr.ny.gov.

Good Cause Eviction

Is 216 East 5 Street covered by Good Cause Eviction?

New York's Good Cause Eviction law (effective April 20, 2024) gives many market-rate tenants the right to renew their lease and challenge rent hikes above the annual local rent standard. It doesn't apply to every building.

Likely covered. Based on public records, market-rate units here appear to fall under Good Cause Eviction protections — tenants may have the right to a lease renewal and to challenge rent increases above the local rent standard (inflation + 5%, capped at 10%).
Built before 2009
Yes
Landlord owns 11+ units
12 units across 1 bldg
Not owner-occupied
No owner-occupancy

Good Cause also excludes condos & co-ops, subsidized/regulated housing, and units renting above 245% of Fair Market Rent — signals we can't always confirm from public data. Not legal advice. Learn more at nyc.gov or call 311 for the Tenant Helpline.

How we score buildings

How 216 East 5 Street's risk score is calculated

We trained a model on 7 years of city inspection data — HPD violation filings, tenant complaints, and owner track records across their entire portfolio. It estimates the probability that HPD inspectors will find serious or dangerous violations at this address in the next 12 months. Lower % = safer.

What the score means for you

Neighborhood percentile
3rdpercentile

Out of 1555 buildings in this neighborhood, 62 have a higher predicted risk. The band is relative to this neighborhood, so a share of every neighborhood falls in each colour.

RiskiestSafest
12-Month risk forecast
High failure risk
in the next 12 months
95%
Risk factors

What's driving this score

These are the three data points that most influenced this building's score — ranked by how much weight the model placed on each one.

Serious violations last 1–2 years

HPD found serious or dangerous conditions at this address recently — the strongest signal of problems ahead.

Hazardous violations (past 7 years)

HPD violations classified as hazardous — things like mold, peeling lead paint, or broken heat.

Emergency violations (past 7 years)

HPD violations classified as immediately dangerous — fires, raw sewage, no heat in winter.

Don't stop here — this is just the surface.

The full report adds 30+ data sets, complete violation history, landlord portfolio and court record. Or keep reading free:

See the full report Event timeline Compare nearby
Building characteristics
Total units12
Floors5
Year built1866
Gross area6,853 sq ft
Building class—
Tax abatementNone
Issue trend & model projection

Violations & complaints per year — solid line is historical record, dashed line is AI projection.

Who's behind the building

216 East 5 Street's landlord & ownership

The people and companies registered to this building, the other properties they run, and their court record. A landlord's wider portfolio is often the best predictor of how your building will be treated.

HPD registration

Filed Oct 16, 2025, expired Sep 1, 2026 .

Registration expired

The registration on file expired Sep 1, 2026. HPD requires owners of most rental buildings to re-register every year.

City records, not real time — sale and registration data are as fresh as the last extract loaded; the ACRIS deed record above is good through Aug 31, 2020.

Corporate Owner

Registered contact for this building.

Address
260 West Broadway 9f
New York, NY 10013
Landlord portfolio

Other properties owned.

Loading…
Recorded with the city

216 East 5 Street's mortgage & ownership history

Deeds, mortgages, assignments and satisfactions recorded against this property with the NYC Automated City Register Information System (ACRIS) — the public paper trail behind who owns it and who has lent against it.

5 records on file

Create a free account to see this building's deeds, mortgages, assignments and satisfactions — who owns it and who has lent against it.

Create free account

Sourced from NYC ACRIS recorded documents. Amounts reflect the mortgage or transfer amount stated on the recorded document, not necessarily the property's market value.

What residents say

Reviews from 216 East 5 Street tenants

Real experiences from people who have lived here. Share your honest feedback to help others make informed decisions.

Share your experience — Help other renters by leaving an honest review

Create account

Loading reviews…

On the map

Compare nearby alternatives

This building and nearby alternatives, color-coded by risk level. Click any marker to explore.

Buildings nearby
8 found
The story over time

216 East 5 Street event timeline

Violations, complaints, fines, and permits — the most recent records on file, in order.

2026
311 Call Aug 26
Rodent
Rat Sighting
311 Call Aug 23
Rodent

See all 31 events

Full history back to 2015 — violations, complaints, permits, bedbug filings, and more.

Unlock full timeline
Every record we have

Full data for 216 East 5 Street apartments

30+ public city datasets for this address — searchable and sortable.

Side by side

How 216 East 5 Street compares to the neighborhood

This building against comparable properties in East Village. Toggle filters to narrow the peer group.

Loading comparables…
Checking out an apartment?

Look up the next building before you sign

Most renters check three or four buildings. Search any NYC address free — no account needed to see the rating.

Search another address Get full report
Simple pricing

Get the full picture

Every plan unlocks the complete report: all 30+ record sets, full history, landlord portfolio and court record, plus PDF & Excel exports.

Pay once

Report Bundle

For the buildings you're deciding on right now

$10one time

3premium reports

$3.33 per report · charged once, never renews

Each credit unlocks one building's premium report for 30 days.

  • 3 premium reports — AI executive summary included
  • Live data across all 27 public record types
  • 200 records per dataset
  • PDF & Excel exports included
  • Compare up to 10 buildings side-by-side
  • Credits never expire until you use them
Buy 3 Reports — $10
Pay once

Apartment Hunter

For a wide search across many buildings

$39one time

30premium reports

$1.30 per report · charged once, never renews

Each credit unlocks one building's premium report for 30 days.

  • 30 premium reports — AI executive summary included
  • Live data across all 27 public record types
  • 200 records per dataset
  • PDF & Excel exports included
  • Compare up to 10 buildings side-by-side
  • Credits never expire until you use them
Buy 30 Reports — $39
Most Popular Current plan
Subscription

Renter

For the weeks when the stakes are highest

$8.33/mo

5premium reports / mo

Billed $100/year — save $44 vs monthly

Renews automatically until you cancel.

  • Unlimited standard reports — 50 records per dataset
  • 5 premium AI reports per month — live data, 200 records per dataset, all 27 record types
  • PDF & Excel exports on every report
  • Compare up to 10 buildings side-by-side
  • Full event timeline — every year of history
  • Landlord portfolio & ownership insights
Start Your Search

Less than $0.28/day. Cancel anytime.

Cancel anytime · Data sourced from NYC Open Data, HPD, DOB, DOF & the courts

Watch 216 East 5 Street
Get an email the moment a new violation or complaint is filed.