58 Carmelita St, San Francisco, CA 94117

58 Carmelita Street is a two-unit, two-story multi-family residential building constructed in 1900, currently owned by Andra Dee Young. The property experienced a major fire incident on February 14, 2023, which resulted in significant damage to the front 25 feet of the building, affecting the roof, walls, and various systems. Following the fire, the building underwent multiple phases of repair, including asbestos debris cleanup in June 2023 ($95,000), extensive fire repairs in July 2023 ($500,000), and subsequent revisions to the porch framing in December 2024 ($1).

The property has received extensive electrical and plumbing updates in September 2024, including rough-in electrical work and new fixtures for both units, as well as the installation of new gas furnaces and water service replacement. The building's post-fire recovery period has been marked by several significant concerns, including multiple complaints regarding environmental hazards. There were documented issues with improper asbestos debris removal in July 2023, concerns about toxic particulates and off-gassing in March-April 2023, and structural stability questions following the fire.

Most recently, in July 2024, there has been an active complaint regarding construction work allegedly encroaching onto an adjacent property. The property has also had multiple 311 calls regarding various issues, including graffiti (September 2024), though these are generally unrelated to the building's primary concerns. Historical records show minor maintenance work in the 1990s, including reroofing and stair replacement, but the focus now remains on the extensive repairs and remediation work following the 2023 fire. The building is currently under active monitoring due to the remaining violations from the 2023 fire incident.